Blackfathom4▾

Recent notifications

Your trade with Mathae has been contested. Contested · 20 minutes ago
Your bid on War Brig Deed has been raised to 4,250. Bid · 1 hour ago
You have been outbid on Black Bicorne. Bid · 3 hours ago
Familiar: Monkey sold to Mathae for 12,900. Trade · 5 hours ago
Your review of Cutlass Kate has been contested. Contested · yesterday

Contest a review

Review left on you by Mathae · trade #T-20411 · 2 weeks ago

1. The review you are contesting

Item traded	Iron ×500
Agreed price	2,050,000
Trade confirmed	2 weeks ago
Left by	Mathae
Review	−rep

“Seller took nearly an hour to show up and then wanted to renegotiate the quantity. Would not trade again.”

2. Why is it unfair?

Reason

What actually happened?

A paragraph is plenty. Be specific and stick to the facts.

3. Evidence (optional but very helpful)

Attachment 1

Attachment 2

Up to two attachments, 10 MB each.

What contesting does. The review is not deleted. It is hidden from your public profile and taken out of your reputation score while a moderator investigates. They then either restore it, or nullify it permanently — in which case it stays on record for staff but never counts against you again.

Never mind, go back

What happens next

The review is hidden from the public while the case is open.
Mathae is notified that their review has been contested.
A moderator reads both sides.
They restore the review, nullify it, or dismiss the contest.

Contested reviews

Anyone can contest a review left on them, but only a moderator can decide the outcome. Contesting is not a way to erase fair criticism — reports that are plainly vexatious are themselves noted.

Layout preview — signed in as: Math (admin) | Blackfathom (moderator) | Blackfathom (player) | signed out · badge: with count | empty (scaffolding only)